Media Births
While reading another blog the other day, some things were brought to my attention that I hadn’t really thought about before. The blog was vbacadventure and the post was about media births. A commenter, Kara, pointed out some media births (on the show “Friends”) that weren’t the typical horrifying portrayal of childbirth we usually see on TV shows.
I like Kara’s point, but “Friends” happens to be our favorite show, maybe the birth scenes are part of the reason why. The labors that took place over their 10 years on the air were not without “complications” but were all natural birth (without drugs or other medical interventions). Phoebe gives birth to triplets, Rachel’s baby was breech, and Monica and Chandler adopt twins, all of which were vaginally delivered babies. They do make those birthing scenes funny while empathizing with a laboring woman. Laughs during labor can help to ease stress anyway, so it could be helpful to remember these scenes. As they say, “Laughter is the best medicine.” Russell kept me laughing and it helped a lot I think (but so did being on my own turf and doing things my way).
While these TV births aren’t exactly realistic either, I do feel they are more along the lines of what childbirth can and should be. When Rachel is in labor, we even see how labor can be different for each woman. She sits there half distraught because a few other women come in and go to the birthing room while she is waiting to do the same. (Another reason I enjoy home birth, my progress is not compared with anyone else’s.) Each one of those women handled the experience a little differently, just like we do for real. One of them appears to feel practically no pain, as she just makes little “mm” sounds during her contractions and then says, “That was a big one!” afterwards. Another woman is loud, miserable and cussing at her husband, but not because of “pain.”
Obstetricians have been trained for worst case scenarios and anything less than that is a bore to most of them. I don’t think they realize their brilliance when they help a woman successfully give birth to a baby without drugs or medical intervention. It would make all their time in med-school seem like a waste (until the rare occasion where that knowledge comes in handy despite all other efforts, to actually save lives rather than control “progress”). There is certainly a time and place for medical interventions, but the media should not promote them by showing such b.s. so often that millions of women actually expect to need those interventions.
Birth should be a time to celebrate family (like “Friends” also portrays: Ross and Susan agreeing on a baby name, Phoebe settling for being the favorite aunt when she has to “give up” the triplets, Joey promising Rachael she won’t be alone, and Monica not separating the twins),it should not be about fear of pains.
There is no cookie cutter for childbirth, but the dough is basically the same. If we are all starting out with the same kind of dough, our cookies shouldn’t be all that different, but it depends on the circumstances in the kitchen. In other words, in case you didn’t get my metaphors, women are women. We have the same parts that make us women and those parts have the same functional potential. The differences in our labors can be caused by a variety of factors like the support we have or don’t have, our comfort level in our birthing places, the attendants we have, and the tools that are or are not used and the timing of such things.
I personally hate stirrups, unless they are attached to a saddle sitting on a horses back. I feel that when my body is good and ready, it will open up, I don’t need some cold, hard, un-feeling things baring my all for somebody else’s convenience. When the baby is ready to show, the baby shows. Making a woman spread herself this way isn’t going to make childbirth happen any quicker, especially if she’s not comfortable doing such a thing in the first place. The stirrup factor is something I’ve also seen a lot in TV births, along with back laying, fear, screaming, loved ones in the waiting room instead of supporting the laboring woman, and women being portrayed as completely unreasonable, even crazy, during labor. It’s not right.
So for a more accurate portrayal of childbirth in the media, I refer you to “Friends”. Season 5 episode 3 called “The One Hundredth” (Phoebe’s birth of the triplets), season 8 the last episode called “The One Where Rachel Has a Baby”, and season 10 “The Last One” (Erica gives birth to the twins that Monica and Chandler adopt). Also, the first “Friends” childbirth scene was when Carol (Ross’ lesbian ex-wife) gives birth in season 1, the second to last episode called “The One With the Birth.”
It was a great show, well written, with a great cast and some great birth stories given a funny twist to show the lighter side of childbirth.
By the way, every one of those childbirth episodes makes me tear up because they are emotionally griping to me, in a good way. So there are your birth stories for today. Watch ‘em if you can and if you see them during your pregnancy, be aware that you may also cry.
Sheilah ![]()
Popularity: 39% [?]
Technorati Tags: childbirth, natural birth, baby, breech, labor, pregnancy
Popularity: 39% [?]
posted in Birth Stories, Child Birth, Natural Birth, Pregnancy | 0 Comments